How to Start Christmas Shopping in October

Everyone knows the advice: start early. Almost nobody follows it, and the people who do frequently end up worse off than the people who did not, because starting early without a plan means buying more, not buying sooner.

The classic failure is familiar. You buy three thoughtful things in October, forget you bought them, buy replacements in December, find the originals in January, and spend the year with a cupboard full of gifts for people whose birthdays have passed. Starting early only works if it is attached to a list.

October Is for Deciding, Not Buying

Reframe the month. The scarce resource in December is not money or shipping time — it is decisions. Every gift requires working out who the person is, what they might want, what you spent last year, and whether anyone else is buying the same thing. Doing twelve of those in the third week of December is why the season feels like work.

So October's job is the deciding. Write the names down. All of them, including the awkward ones — the neighbour, the mail carrier, the new partner of a sibling, the teacher, the person whose name you always remember on the 22nd. That list is the entire foundation, and it takes twenty minutes.

Then put a number beside each name. Not a gift, a number. The total is your budget and you will be shocked by it, which is the point of doing this in October rather than on your credit card statement in January.

Buy the Things That Get Worse With Time

Some purchases genuinely should happen now, and they fall into three groups.

Anything personalised, engraved, printed or made to order. Turnaround times stretch dramatically through November and the good makers close their books entirely. If you want a photo book, a custom print or anything with a name on it, October is not early — it is on time.

Anything from a small or independent seller. They make a year's revenue in eight weeks and they run out. The item you saw in September will not necessarily exist in December.

Anything shipping from far away, or to somewhere remote. Cross-border parcels, anything going north, anything going to a small community served by one carrier. Add weeks, not days.

Wait on the Things That Get Cheaper

Electronics, appliances, toys and anything from a large retailer are the wrong things to buy in October, because they will be meaningfully cheaper in the last week of November.

What you should do in October is note the current price. This is the single most useful five minutes in the whole process. A sale price only means something against a real baseline, and a lot of November discounts are measured against a number nobody paid all year. If you know a mixer was $189 in October, you can tell instantly whether $149 in November is a deal.

Write those numbers down next to the item. Future you, scrolling at 11pm on Black Friday, will not remember.

Ask Now, While It Is a Normal Question

In October, "what would you actually like this year?" is a relaxed question. In December it is a deadline. The answers you get are better and more honest, because nobody feels rushed into naming something.

This is also the moment to raise anything structural — proposing a name draw instead of everyone buying for everyone, suggesting a spending cap, agreeing that the adults will skip each other and focus on the kids. All of those are easy conversations in October and impossible in December, because by then people have already bought.

If money is tight this year, this is the month to say so. Nobody minds. Everybody minds finding out after they have spent.

Write Down What You Bought

This is the step that separates people who start early successfully from people who just start early.

Keep one list, in one place, with three columns: who, what, and where it is. The last column matters more than it sounds. A gift bought in October and hidden well is a gift you will find in February. Note the hiding place. Note it even if you are certain you will remember, because you will not.

Add the price too. It is the only way to keep the budget honest, and it stops the very common pattern where you buy one person a modest thing in October, forget, and buy them something substantial in December.

Do Not Overbuy the Early Names

Everyone shops for the easy people first, because ideas arrive fastest for them. The predictable result is that the three easiest people on your list get two gifts each and the four hardest get a gift card bought in a panic.

Cap it. One gift per person until everybody has one. Only then go back and add. This single rule does more for the fairness of a Christmas than any amount of budgeting.

What to Do in November

If October went properly, November is short. You buy the discounted items you priced in October, you place the last orders that need shipping time, and you check the list for the two or three names you still have nothing for.

December, in theory, is wrapping and food. It will not be entirely, because it never is, but the difference between a December with four remaining decisions and a December with sixteen is the difference between a nice month and an errand.

The other thing worth doing now is putting up your own list. Everyone reading this is also somebody else's difficult name, and the person planning ahead for you in October would very much like to know what you want.

Keep browsing

More ideas in the most wished for gifts.

Or create your own free wishlist — add gifts from any store, share one link, and let people claim what they are buying so nothing arrives twice.